Is a Landlord or Property Owner Liable for an Assault or Unsafe Conditions in Pennsylvania?

Is a Landlord or Property Owner Liable for an Assault or Unsafe Conditions in Pennsylvania?If you’re injured in an assault, fire, or other dangerous condition on someone else’s property, you could be left with medical bills, lost wages, and other financial losses. In some cases, the property owner may be liable. Pennsylvania law doesn’t automatically make a landlord or business responsible when someone is hurt on their premises; liability is dependent on the source of the danger and whether the property owner was negligent in a way that contributed to the injury.

Negligent security and premises liability cases can be fairly complicated when someone else causes intentional harm, as is the case in an assault. Knowing what the property owner knew and the steps they took to ensure safety may be important. Wondering if you have a valid premises liability case in Pennsylvania? Call Fellerman & Ciarimboli Law, P.C. now.

When Can Unsafe Property Conditions Lead to a Pennsylvania Premises Liability Claim?

Property owners often have a duty to take reasonable steps to maintain their premises and address dangerous conditions in an appropriate amount of time. The specific duty they have can depend on why the injured person was on the property, which determines whether they’re an invitee, licensee, or trespasser.

Property owners may be responsible when they fail to address dangerous conditions, such as broken stairs or handrails, poor lighting, blocked exits, or defective doors and windows. This doesn’t mean that a property owner must immediately address every dangerous condition; however, they should take reasonable steps to correct it in an appropriate amount of time.

Whether an owner has notice of a hazard also comes into play. Consider a broken stairway. The property owner may claim that they had no knowledge of it and no reason to know about it. But looking at the maintenance request logs may show that multiple tenants made repair requests in the months leading up to the accident, indicating that the owner knew or should have known about it.

Finally, when it comes to landlords, Pennsylvania law differentiates between injuries caused by physical property defects and injuries caused by another person’s criminal conduct. This could also affect your claim.

When Could a Landlord Be Liable for an Apartment Fire Injury?

If you were injured in an apartment fire, the fact that the fire happened on rented property doesn’t automatically make the landlord liable. The investigation may instead focus on why the fire occurred and whether an unsafe condition played a role in your injuries.

For example, a landlord could be liable for an apartment fire injury if the fire was caused by a negligently maintained electrical system, known fire hazards, or required safety equipment that was not maintained and contributed to the injuries.

You will also need to prove that the owner’s or landlord’s negligence caused your injuries. Proving the negligent condition and proving that it led to your injuries are two separate things.

Can a Property Owner Or Landlord Be Liable When Someone Is Assaulted?

Potential liability for an assault depends in part on the relationship between the injured person and the property owner. Residential landlords don’t have a broad duty to protect tenants from criminal acts by outside parties simply because they are landlords. However, in Feld v. Merriam, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a landlord can assume additional responsibilities if they choose to do so. If they do, they must use reasonable care in carrying them out. If they act negligently and that negligence leads to harm, they may be liable.

Different rules apply to businesses that invite members of the public onto their property. Pennsylvania law generally recognizes that a business may have a duty to take reasonable precautions against a third party’s harmful conduct if they know or should reasonably anticipate that conduct.

What Evidence is Helpful in a Negligent Security Or Premises Liability Case?

Negligent security cases are highly fact-specific, so a thorough investigation is necessary if you plan on pursuing compensation. Your premises liability attorney may look at:

  • Security provisions in the lease
  • Representations made to tenants about security
  • Security guards and patrol schedules
  • Locks and entry systems
  • Surveillance cameras
  • Reports of broken security equipment
  • Previous criminal incidents
  • Circumstances of the assault

If you were injured by an unsafe condition on the property, the investigation may focus more on what unsafe condition existed, how long it existed, and whether the property owner had actual or constructive notice of it. Having evidence of the dangerous condition can be useful, which is why we often recommend securing photos or video footage before leaving.

Surveillance footage can also be very beneficial in both negligent security and general premises liability claims. However, surveillance footage doesn’t last indefinitely. Depending on how a property’s system is set up, footage may be overwritten in a matter of weeks. Working with a premises liability attorney makes it easier to preserve and access important evidence early.

Can a Bar Be Liable if You Get Hurt in a Fight?

The bar may potentially be partially liable if you’re hurt in a fight there. A lot comes down to the specific facts, such as what happened before the incident, what happened during the incident, and whether the bar acted negligently.

Important evidence may include previous violent incidents, threats made prior to the fight, employees’ knowledge of an escalating confrontation, and whether staff had a reasonable opportunity to respond.

Because of this, a sudden and unforeseeable assault can have a very different legal outcome than an attack that occurred after an extended verbal confrontation.

What Do You Have to Prove in a Negligent Security Or Premises Liability Case?

These cases generally come down to four basic elements: duty, breach, causation, and damages.

Duty looks at the duty of care owed to you by a property owner or landlord. The breach refers to their failure to uphold that duty. You must then prove that their failure to uphold their duty caused or contributed to your injuries. Finally, you have to prove that you have damages. These often include medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

Talk to a Pennsylvania Premises Liability Attorney Now

If you’ve been injured on someone else’s property and you’re unsure whether you have a viable claim, our team is here to help. Contact us online to get started.

 

Leave a Comment